Trilogy Financial, a privately-held financial planning firm with more than $2 billion in client assets, utilizes a combination of our latest technology and broad perspective to help you advance your tomorrows.

Is It Possible to Contribute TOO Much to your 401(k)?

March 02, 2016

It's that time of year again...TAX TIME. But will you be seeing some of your 401(k) money coming back to you?

It is that time of year again when some employees will get notices from their employer stating they are getting money back from their 401(k) due to over contributing.  The typical reaction of most people is to check their contributions from the year before assuming they must have put in over $18,000, the current limit for those under age 50.  However, what most affected employees will find is that they did not go over the $18,000 limit.  If fact, many will be significantly restricted and will not get anywhere near the $18,000 contribution they expected. 

Unfortunately (or fortunately depending on your perspective), there are discrimination rules that govern 401(k) plans. The impact can be that regular employees with no ownership or power to change the direction of the company policies are limited in how much they can save for retirement in a tax-preferential way.  The good news is that there are a few alternatives outside the 401(k) to help those who are affected by these rules. 

The first options to consider are a traditional IRA and Roth IRA both of which provide more tax benefits then the other options listed below. A traditional IRA will most likely be an option for only a few higher income earners so make sure to see the phase out details.   Alternatively, the next option is to contribute to a Roth IRA, but there are limitations for higher income earners that can be found here.  Also consider having your spouse contribute to one of these plans if their employer does not offer a retirement plan.

Options with no income restrictions would include funding a non-deductible IRA or a non-qualified annuity.  While these two options are not tax deductible like a traditional IRA and are not tax free like the Roth IRA, they are tax deferred which is still a valuable benefit when compared to a regular taxable account. The tax deferred account will compound without the added drag of taxes each year, resulting in the ability to compound faster.  

In many cases, the problem of corrective distributions lies with the fact that many of the larger 401(k) providers only offer cookie cutter plan design options with their own product.  With some thoughtful conversation and exploration with someone that has experience in solving these problems, an alternative plan design may fix the corrective distributions.  If you have influence with your employer it might be time to ask them to consult a specialist in this area.

**NPC does not provide tax nor legal advice.

user profile

Written by: Tom Elkins

Tom Elkins is a financial planner and the regional VP based out of the Boston office of Trilogy.  As a former teacher Tom makes it a point to help his clients learn more about the various financial bridges they need to cross so they can make informed decisions.  Over the past 15 years he has built a successful career working with high net worth families and closely held businesses.  Tom is also an outdoor enthusiast who regularly mountain bikes, seeks adventure hiking with his family, or can be found camping under the stars.  On rainy New England days Tom will often spend time in his woodshop building furniture.      

Connect with me on social media!

Blog Archive

Follow Us on the Web



All information herein has been prepared solely for informational purposes and is not an offer to buy, sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security or instrument or to participate in any particular trading strategy. Advisory services provided by TrilogyCapital, Inc, a Registered Investment Adviser. Separate advisory and securities services may be provided by National Planning Corporation (NPC), a SEC Registered Investment Adviser and broker-dealer. Member FINRA and SIPC. Certain registered representative with NPC are doing business under the name of Trilogy Financial. TrilogyCapital, Inc. and Trilogy Financial are affiliated by common ownership and are separate and unrelated to NPC. Please consult with your representative to confirm, on which company's behalf services are being provided. Registered Representatives of NPC may transact securities business in a particular state only if first registered, excluded or exempted from Broker-Dealer, agent or Investment Adviser Representative requirements. In addition, follow-up conversations or meetings with individuals in a particular state that involve either the effecting or attempting to affect transactions in securities or the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation will not be made absent compliance with state Broker-Dealer, agent or Investment Adviser Representative registration requirements or an applicable exemption or exclusion. Content is for general purposes only and is not an offer to buy or sell any security. NPC does not provide tax or legal advice.NPC Privacy Policy.